Who is a tide fan and who is an all fan ? Do you use either just because of the price? Or just for the cleaning power ? I have to say I have both in my stock pile but you know its got to be Tide to get those tough super dirty stains out. I do like All but its not as strong as Tide. BUT I am getting ready to make my own washing liquid . My friend has gave me the recipe to make it and I am so ready to spend less for any washing products . My biggest problem is that some of the washing liquids , after washing my clothes in it , makes me itch so I use the "free " of dyes and perfumes . The homemade is supposed to be for sensitive skin so that is already a plus.